Residential
communities especially Condos DO NOT take advantage of the information and
metrics available today in getting control of their maintenance.
Many Property Managers do not fully understand what
maintenance is.
It is NOT just fixing something when it is broken
Most Board of Directors DO NOT understand what is required
in the maintenance of a community, they just see dollars being spent, not the
saving resulting from those expenditures down the road.
Many companies and associations utilize the term Maintenance
Manager, Facilities Manager and do not understand and are highly surprised when
people apply and request high salaries.
The reason is within the title being proposed, first
"manager" what the company or Association is seeking is a maintenance
man not a manager, second is the term "Maintenance or Facilities"
these are experts in the management and operations of very complex mechanical
systems, EMS (energy management systems), ABS (Automated Building systems) this
is where specific systems of a property are automated or BAS ( Building
Automated Systems) This is where the entire building and all systems are
automated. Are you hiring a Brain surgeon to medicate a bruised arm....No of
course not, so why hire a $100K per year professional when your seeking a
handyman. If your seeking a hire Maintenance professional than advertise for
that quality of professional ( try: www.condospecialties.biz), there are many
titles for the people and each designates a level of experience. Also do not
refer to your custodians or housekeeping staff as maintenance employees, they
are cleaning people Yes they maintain the interior or grounds but what is there
function....Cleaning NOT repair.
Not only the mechanical systems, but the building itself, as
well as the grounds, pools and related systems. These are educated
professionals with numerous certifications and years of education.
Any Building or Property can use the services of a
professional facilities expert, if you are considering a Preventive Maintenance
Program, seeking a reduction in operating expenses, want better control of your
maintenance costs, want the repairs completed properly the first time, than go
to a qualified professional, just as you select a Doctor for a specific problem
select your maintenance professional the same way. ( need assistance try:
www.condospecialties.com)
We have offered the chart below
to assist you the Property Management Company or Association to see exactly
where your dollars are going and how much is being spent on maintenance and operations.
You may be surprised!!!!!
Benchmarking Your
Maintenance Cost
Maintenance costs are usually the second largest single expense component
for facilities... right behind Utility Costs. For some FM's they are the
largest single expense. Facility Managers can have significant impacts on their
operating costs by understanding how they are performing relative to others and
what opportunities exist to reduce or control maintenance costs. The
information you need to benchmark is the:
Cost of your maintenance
activities
Facility areas normalized by
types of space since there are significant differences in maintenance
activity based on the function.
Step 1—Maintenance Benchmarking Definitions…
Maintenance Costs:
Building Maintenance is the preventive and remedial upkeep of building
components i.e., maintenance work done as a normal part of building maintenance
operations.
Standard Costs—Internal and Contracted—Include all costs whether there is a
specific "Craft" sub-category listed or not. For most organizations,
the sum of line D1 will equal the building maintenance budget.
Exceptional Costs—Internal and Contracted—includes major expenditures that
are funded by the maintenance budget. For example, normal roof maintenance and
repair would be included in "Standard Costs." However, replacement of
a substantial portion of the roof would be included in "Exceptional
Costs."
Standard Costs
Exceptional
Costs
Craft
Internal Costs ($000)
Contractual Costs ($000)
Internal Costs($000)
Contractual Costs ($000)
HVAC
$
$
$
$
Electrical
$
$
$
$
Plumbing
$
$
$
$
Energy Mgmt / Security Systems
$
$
$
$
Mechanical
$
$
$
$
Waste Water Treatment
$
$
$
$
Reverse Osmosis De-Ionized (RODI) Water
$
$
$
$
Elevators
$
$
$
$
Carpentry
$
$
$
$
Painting
$
$
$
$
Roofing
$
$
$
$
Flooring
$
$
$
$
General Labor
$
$
$
$
Miscellaneous
$
$
$
$
Maintenance Support assistance from Plant Engineering
$
$
$
$
Supervision & Management
$
$
$
$
Clerical
$
$
$
$
Building Operators
$
$
$
$
Trouble Call Dispatcher and Equipment
$
$
$
$
Work Order Administration
$
$
$
$
Vehicles—Operation and Maintenance—to support building
maintenance only
$
$
$
$
Parts Ordering/Buyer
$
$
$
$
D1. Total maintenance costs ( $000):
$
$
$
$
Step 2—How Do I Compare With Others…
Once this information is collected it is easy to normalize the data on a
unit cost basis to determine how efficiently your maintenance services are
provided. There are several ways to analyze the normalized data and we will
discuss the advantages and disadvantages of each.
Normalized Based on Gross
Square Feet
Each bar on the chart represents a site's annual maintenance cost per gross square foot
The median consumption is
$1.69/GSF
Note how consistent the
normalized data is for these participants. About 80 percent have reported
a cost of between $0.80 / GSF and $3.90 / GSF. There are only a few sites
with very low or very high consumption rates.
But that is still quite a spread between the low and high cost sites and
suggests there may be a better normalizing factor.
Normalized Based on Factored Gross
Square Feet
Each bar on the chart represents a site's annual maintenance cost on a factored gross square foot (FGSF) basis
The median cost is $1.23 /
FGSF
Note how consistent the
normalized data is for these participants. About 75 percent have reported
a maintenance cost of between $0.70 / FGSF and $2.00 / FGSF. There are
only a few sites with very low or very high costs and these are usually
sites that have just started their benchmarking program.
Especially relevant is how much tighter the spread is between the low and
high cost sites… only about $1.30 when normalized against Factored Gross Square
Feet (FGSF) vs. a spread of $3.10 when normalized against Gross Square Feet
(GSF).
We need to normalize the data against FGSF since the buildings in our study
are all different… some include a floor of call center space that operates 24 X
7 while others may have some data center space with the associated high
maintenance costs.
Step 3—Using This Information…
You've completed your maintenance data collection and performed the
calculations. Here are a few questions you should ask yourself…
Where do you stand on these
charts? Are you above the median or below it?
Could you explain to
management why your positions on the charts is just right or needs to be
changed?
What are some of the reasons
that explain your positions on the charts?
Step 4—Some Best Practices…
·Look at your top non-scheduled, breakdown
type, work requests and identify what could be done to reduce them. For
example, our benchmarking participants report a significant reduction in the
amount of hot and cold calls simply by creating a circulation space around the
perimeter.
·Look for improved technology to reduce your
maintenance costs. Many of the same issues that you may evaluate to reduce
energy costs also reduce maintenance costs. More efficient lighting,
installation of variable frequency drives, installation of energy efficient
chillers and high efficiency motors will reduce your costs.
·Communicate the programs you are implementing
with your occupants in a regular and routine way. A facility manager
implemented a new building management system that allowed for temperature
control from a centralized location. Complaints went up since the users thought
no one was responding to their requests. A brown bag lunch program that
explained how the system worked and displays in the Facility Management office
was the solution to that communication problem.
Participants By
Industry Type
Space Metrics
Space Utilization 430 Gross Square
Feet per Occupant
Where does your
community fit in? ...........or does it!
You can convert this chart to Per UNIT costs a little more
difficult initally, however you may find it better when addressing the
community.
It is proven many times over that a site specific Preventive Maintenance
Program will reduce operating costs, however it is not instant it takes years
to see and document the results. A site specific preventive maintenance program
is the optimum program, however it is custom build not an off the shelf generic
program which is usless in our industry.
Our consulting company has worked with communities and have generated notable
saving during the life span of a community, in some cases they have generated
saving that have lead to a percentage rebate of association maintenance fees.
Based on the community, size, age, environmental conditions, present
maintenance programs ( if any) and the interest and support of the Board we
have seen costs like $1100 per unit reduced to a little over $500 per unit over
a three to four year program. This is not to say every program will provide
these results but there will be a reduction in costs, the goal is not the
reduction but to enhance the longivity of the equipment (cost reduction),
reduced down time, reduced unforseen failures, planned repair and replacement
of major pieces of equipment or systems and more.
Regardless of Who you choose to provide your Preventive Maintenance Program ,
SSPM (Site Specific Preventive Maintenance) Pays, today, tomorrow and way into
the future.
Regardless of style from single family homes to mega hi-rise YOU CAN use a SSPM!